Italian Researchers Say Kids Identifying with Harry Potter Display Less Bias Against Minorities and Immigrants After Reading the Books
In celebration of Harry Potter Victory Day, (May 2, when the Order of the Phoenix and Dumbledore’s Army turned the tide against the death eaters in the Battle of Hogwarts), an NPR story and a Psychology Today article cited a recent Italian study linking identification with Harry to a lower likelihood of bias or prejudice against stigmatized groups.
Harry Potter is, of course, the magically powerful teen with a mixed lineage that some of the pure-bloods of his wizarding otherworld disdain. In the course of the series, many of the aristocratic pure-bloods turn out to be the villains while many of the "mudbloods" (a derogatory term for muggle-born witches and wizards) are the good guys. In this is a message for young readers: being born rich and powerful in an admired group does not guarantee that a person is morally better than someone from a non-traditional background. Another insight: dismiss or abuse underdogs at your own peril.
In his Psychology Today article, Christopher Bergland summarized the Italian findings this way:
The Special Role of Speculative Fiction
Speculative fiction has a strong history of opening characters’ (and readers’) minds through encounters with diverse characters and creatures, and has suffered backlashes for it. The most recent example is the upheaval at this year's Hugo Award nominations. In scifi, a protagonist may suddenly face invaders with divergent worldviews or opposing galactic priorities (like the Vogons in The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, who disregard the sentients on Earth to destroy it because they need to build an interplanetary highway through it. Don't panic.)
Speculative fiction which takes this question seriously can force readers to examine their own biases. SF/F can examine discrimination by placing it in a less controversial fictional setting of an otherworld. Writers can create conflicts and illuminate discrimination between groups paralleling our own without risk of offending actual intolerant groups.
Another example is Ursula K Le Guin’s classic The Left Hand of Darkness, which sends Genly Ai to planet Winter where the androgynous people kemmer monthly into one or the other sex as needed to reproduce inside their relationships. Genly can’t read the signals of one of the world’s leaders, Estraven, because s/he seems “effeminate,” and Genly can't help but mistrust Estraven because of it. Later the two must grow to trust and sacrifice for each other to survive a difficult journey out of a nightmarish arctic work camp.
Le Guin’s book, published in the 1960s, questioned readers' assumption that leaders are male and that this is good. She implies that worlds with no such duality would suffer fewer misunderstandings or wars, despite that Genly comes from a people who can “mindspeak” with each other, and he misses that open communication deeply. More generally, the book asks us to think about what it is that we love in others. Don’t we all hope that it’s something deeper than appearance, parts and adherence to gender-determined roles?
Does Reading in General Build Empathy?
In the Psychology Today article, Bergland goes on to explain why reading the Harry Potter books is mind-expanding:
Other recent research shows that readers’ brains experience story events as if they were actually happening to themselves. (This does not happen when viewing TV, BTW.) Readers literally put themselves in the place of the protagonist and experience their frustrations, achievements and setbacks along with them. Careful readers of thoughtful stories learn hard lessons alongside the hero or antihero.
So What is a Writer’s Responsibility?
Writers may complain that readers “missed the point,” but does the research now prove that, biologically speaking, that may not be possible? If readers really “live” each novel through the lens of their own past experiences and learn from it as if it were a part of their own lives, is it legitimate to tell readers what they should learn from their own experiences?
Maybe not, but as Unbound Writers of speculative fiction we can give readers, and especially kids, insights into the difficulties that minorities face and overcome in their everyday lives. Further, we can hope that through our fair presentations, readers will exit the wormhole of a novel with more empathy toward minorities and stigmatized groups, not less.
Read Similar Stories
In Miller's poignant debut novel the power to control and the power to discover truth are superhuman abilities in a world where everything is in doubt.
No one is reading more dark fiction than Ellen Datlow. Her knowledge of the horror genre is deeper than mine or yours.
Helen Oyeyemi proving once again that she is a magical fairy tale spinner with her short story collection, What is Not Yours is Not Yours.
Brenna Yovanoff's Gothic monsters are full of teeth, and she is an author full of surprises.
In praise of complicated heroes in Ken Liu's epic fantasy.
It's Lent. What better time to contemplate Catholics in space? Theodore McCombs and CS Peterson discuss The Sparrow, A Canticle for Leibowitz and The Book of Strange, New Things.
The Reader is a meta-meditation on the mystical act of reading itself. With pirates. And assassins.
Family, identity, and the trouble with relatives living and dead.
Gemma Webster and Theodore McCombs conclude their three-part appreciation of Octavia Butler's groundbreaking Xenogenesis trilogy.
After a politically tumultuous 2016, Jon seeks solace in the fantasy worlds of Beth Cato and V.E. Schwab.
Our favorite books and posts from Year Two.
In our second appreciation of Octavia Butler's Xenogenesis trilogy, we look at the second generation of Lilith's Brood and his embrace of self-determinism, even at the highest costs.
Is the world ready to say goodbye to the docile black man trope?
Unbound Writers, Theodor McCombs and Gemma Webster, bring you the first installment of their appreciation of the Xenogenesis trilogy: Dawn
Fairy tale elements and symbolism in Yaa Gyasi's debut, Homegoing
If you could communicate with the past without changing the present, would you do it? Of course you would.
Authors love to taunt troubled characters with mirrors.
Go big or go home when you're writing about opera.
The interactive nature of video games may not make for the purest, strongest story telling, but this year's E3 proves again games are creating some of the most ambitious speculative universes you can find.
Trivial fiends and ordinary grace in Hilary Mantel's literary fright show.
Two appreciations of Gold Fame Citrus, the debut novel from Claire Vaye Watkins.
Nevada and California battle over water rights on the Colorado River while the city of Phoenix lies in ashes in Paolo Bacigalupi’s post-apocalyptic novel.
Paolo Bacigalupi, the master of the dire sci-fi future, visits Fiction Unbound to talk about black-swan events, speculative fiction's power to contextualize the present, and what he has learned about his own creative process.
It broke my heart, but I did it anyway. I bought an anthology of 72 time travel stories even though not a single one of them was by Jack Finney.
Zelazny's works are essential speculative fiction classics and represent an important step in the evolution of science fiction and fantasy. He mixed various genres to produce entertaining, trail-blazing, genre-bending fiction.
Cromwell is the hero of his own life. Flawed, sure, and antihero most definitely, but hero nonetheless. This strong point of view is an asset in humanizing Cromwell, who is often seen as the cunning right hand to a fickle, sex-crazed violent king -- a role that would typically be characterized as a villain.
Military space opera sends carefully-crafted heroes on bold interplanetary adventures where ethical choices are not always black and white. Complex plots explode with military action, side love interests and high consequences for war's losers, while its themes often explore the consequences of bigotry and prejudice.
In The Lunar Chronicles, Marissa Meyer re-imagines four classic princesses and their associated princes. With the five-book series now complete, it's time to unpack these princesses and see what patterns, new and old, have emerged in their heroic journeys.
In "Revolt 1680/2180," an exhibition at the Denver Art Museum, artist Virgil Ortiz explores a post-apocalyptic world informed by the Pueblo Rebellion of 1680, where the future echoes the past.